I flagged two comments on this question:
Is it code-golf? If so, tag it. If not, define the winning criteria.
And the second flagged comment:
@ugoren sorry not sure where to draw the line, i want shortest within the criteria, is that challenge or golf?
And I flagged them as "obsolete", because they are obsolete: the question is tagged code-golf now, so it has an objective winning criteria now.
So, why are these flags declined?