Should a question be closed based on something the owner said outside of the question, such as in a comment?
This question was posted by a brand new Code Golf user who had problems with English and with his winning criteria. After the English and criteria were fixed, it was closed because of something the poster said in the comments. The phrase that sparked the close was "its just a problem which i cant resolve". In other words, the OP had a problem that he couldn't solve, and so he transformed it into a coding challenge.
Out of fear that this will yield answers filled entirely with personal opinions, I beg the following: please answer if and only if you are familiar with best close (also known as flag) practices on other sites.