# What is the Sandbox?

This "Sandbox" is a place where Code Golf users can get feedback on prospective challenges they wish to post to the main page. This is useful because writing a clear and fully specified challenge on the first try can be difficult. There is a much better chance of your challenge being well received if you post it in the Sandbox first.

See the Sandbox FAQ for more information on how to use the Sandbox.

## Get the Sandbox Viewer to view the sandbox more easily

To add an inline tag to a proposal use shortcut link syntax with a prefix: [tag:king-of-the-hill]

# Produce the next Italy number code-golfintegersequence

This is the third post for the second RGS's Golfing Showdown.

Italy is a Southern European country that was greatly devastated by the impact of the coronavirus crisis in its fairly aged population. As of the 27th of April, Italy was roughly 600 cases short of hitting 200.000 total confirmed cases.

Your task is to produce the total number of confirmed cases on day n+1 given the total number of confirmed cases on day n, with n going from the 21st of February 2020 to the 10th of April 2020, as per Wikipedia's data, obtained at 19:38 27/04/2020 UTC.

For your convenience, these are the 20 numbers involved; the first 19 are inputs and the last 19 are outputs.

[20, 79, 150, 229, 322, 445, 650, 888, 1128, 1694, 2036, 2502, 3089, 3858, 4636, 5883, 7375, 9172, 10149, 12462]


# I/O

I/O should be integers or reasonable representations of those, with the restriction that your code must accept as input its own output.

# Test cases:

20 -> 79
79 -> 150
150 -> 229
229 -> 322
322 -> 445
445 -> 650
650 -> 888
888 -> 1128
1128 -> 1694
1694 -> 2036
2036 -> 2502
2502 -> 3089
3089 -> 3858
3858 -> 4636
4636 -> 5883
5883 -> 7375
7375 -> 9172
9172 -> 10149
10149 -> 12462


Python reference implementation

• Can we use ResourceObject["Epidemic Data for Novel Coronavirus COVID-19"] for Mathematica? (it involves fetching the data from a server, but 1) it's still built-in 2) so do many SomethingData functions for the first time). – my pronoun is monicareinstate Apr 28 at 1:47
• @mypronounismonicareinstate if that is not against some loophole, sure. Just make sure the numbers coincide with the numbers I posted – RGS Apr 28 at 6:00
• How is this not a hard-code the data challenge? Is there any possible relation? Because otherwise, it seems really boring. – S.S. Anne Apr 29 at 0:54
• @S.S.Anne thank you for your feedback; I changed the task and reduced the total amount of days we are dealing with. Please let me know if this looks more sensible. – RGS Apr 29 at 18:40
• It's better, but I still don't see how this couldn't be solved without just a big array. – S.S. Anne Apr 29 at 19:06
• @S.S.Anne someone will think of something! Hopefully :) – RGS Apr 29 at 19:15
• You can't just hope that someone will find some interesting way to solve your challenge to make a boring challenge interesting. The shortest way I see to solve this right now is to hard-code the data, which is probably what everybody will do. – S.S. Anne Apr 29 at 19:22
• Just graph your data, see how much it deviates from only a simple parabola? – S.S. Anne Apr 29 at 19:29
• Maybe you could allow some small error bound on the output (say 10%)? Then the challenge would become about finding a model that approximates the data well, rather than hardcoding values – math junkie Apr 29 at 20:16

# Make an Anti-compressor (WIP)

Create an algorithm that reversibly and losslessly makes files bigger. You must create the anti-compressor. The de-anti-compressor can be your own creation or something that already exists. The two programs do not need to be written in the same language.

### Objective Validity Criteria

• Inputs into the anti-compressor can be binary files using any or all byte values.
• All inputs into your anti-compressor must produce outputs that are at least one byte longer.
• The anti-compressor is losslessly reversible by either an existing program or your own.
• The de-anti-compressor must work on (at least) all possible outputs of the anti-compressor.
• Both the anti-compressor and de-anti-compressor can be executed on an actual computer. Keep execution time within reason (e.g. no $$\O(n!)\$$ programs, please)

This will be a unless I get a good suggestion for an objective scoring system.

My only idea so far is that the score could be based on the decompression ratio, cancelled out by how well gzip compresses the output. Unfortunately, this could be abused easily by inserting arbitrarily large amounts of random padding between significant bits of information, leading to an unbounded score that can always be beaten with trivial modification.

• Besides the usual issues with pop-cons, I'd really have no idea how to vote because the task is so broad and I don't know what's meant to be interesting in an answer. – xnor May 11 at 20:00
• @xnor that's fair. I'm not entirely sure if this challenge is a good idea in the first place, but I got an upvote earlier, so I thought it might be worth it to refine it and see where it goes. I could see the subjective criteria being along the lines of the funniest or most clever way of anti-compressing a file. Injecting filler data, random or not, is not very clever, but having it output an overly verbose java program that outputs the original file when executed is both humorous and clever- but perhaps not as much as other ideas I haven't even thought of. – Beefster May 11 at 23:09
• @Λ̸̸ The issue with that scoring system is that you can always make a file more bloated. Someone doubles every byte? I can just triple every byte. That kind of oneupmanship is not interesting. I can try to put limits on exactly what kind of bloating is allowed so that there is some sort of soft upper bound, but then the challenge becomes one of abusing the rules and finding clever interpretations and loopholes- also not very interesting. – Beefster May 12 at 15:08
• I have an idea: make the answerer choose an existing compression algorithm, and then create an anti-compression program given an input string.The anti-compressed string, when compressed with the chosen algorithm, must produce the exact same output as the input. That way, the anti-compressing method of randomly inserting characters in the input string can be avoided, since there isn't a way to un-double speak a given input character, and for a string with randomly inserted characters, the compressor will not know which characters to leave out during the compression. – user92069 May 13 at 2:36
• Given that, the scoring criterion can now be simply code-golf, since there isn't a way to create boring answers, and the only possible way to score answers left is just code-golf. – user92069 May 13 at 2:38
• @Λ̸̸ At that point, it would make more sense to make a jillion different code-golf challenges since this essentially defines an entire class of golfing challenges. – Beefster May 13 at 16:32

# Print all sequenced variants of the SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) genome in FASTA format

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genbank/sars-cov-2-seqs/

The FASTA format has the name of the sequence data following a >, a newline, 60 characters of As, Ts, Cs, and Gs, a newline, 60 characters of As, Ts, Cs, and Gs, and so on.

You need only print the name of the, not the location it came from. For example:

>XX-NNNNNN.N
GENOMIC DATA GOES HERE
>XX-NNNNNN.N
MORE GENOMIC DATA GOES HERE

• I can't imagine what good does requiring newlines every 60 characters do to the challenge. That site also has very many files linked, and you have not specified which ones we need to use, nor you provided us with the expected output (a plain link to a random website where we have to scrape and parse several thousands of files you haven't told us about is not enough). Since there are thousands of them, I strongly suspect suspect that zpaq will win this time. – my pronoun is monicareinstate Jun 14 at 8:13

# Wuhan Xi Estimates

Challenge
Create a program that takes two base-ten integer number inputs (w,x). The program should output the closest integer number that is x order of magnitude smaller than w, rounded downwards. The output should be zero if the result is less than 1.

Test cases

f(10,1) = 1
f(10,2) = 0
f(1000000, 3) = 1000
f(888, 2) = 8
f(99999, 4) = 9
f(7777777, 8) = 0
f(123455, 5) = 1
f(123455, 4) = 12345
f(123455, 0) = 123455


Example Code
Here's an ungolfed example in Lua:


a,b=b:match("([^,]+),([^,]+)")

if (b+0 > #a) then
print(0)
else
d = (a+0)/(10^b)
print (math.floor(d))
end



Try it online!

General rules

• This is , so shortest code in bytes in its respective language wins.

• Standard rules apply for your answer with default I/O rules, so you are allowed to use STDIN (with the specification above)/STDOUT, functions/method with the proper parameters and return-type, full programs.

• Default Loopholes are forbidden.

• Can we take input as string where the two numbers are separated by "E-" ? – Adám Jun 22 at 21:52
• @Adám, Is "E-" executable code? If so, I guess that's fine, but it has to be part of the byte count. If it is just a glorified separator, or a switch of some kind, then yes and doesn't have to be included in the byte count. – ouflak Jun 23 at 5:55
• My idea what that one could do something like floor(input) where input is e.g. 888E-2 thus trivialising the challenge. – Adám Jun 23 at 5:57
• @Adám, That would be fine, and the challenge will have many 'trivial' answers in several languages. I'd be surprised if there isn't atleast a few 2/3 byte solutions. – ouflak Jun 23 at 6:00
• Maybe mention in the challenge text that this amounts to computing $⌊w×10^{-x}⌋$? – Adám Jun 23 at 6:10
• @Adám, There are other ways to look at it. My Turing Machine Code solution certainly won't be computing any powers. – ouflak Jun 23 at 6:34
• Is that integers or positive integers? ;) – Trebor Jun 23 at 16:07
• The wording 'closest integer number that is $x$ order of magnitude smaller than $w$' is ambiguous. I initially interpreted it to mean, e.g., f(1000000, 3) = 9999 (closest integer to 1000000 that is 3 orders of magnitude smaller). As Adám said above, it seems that you're just asking for $\lfloor w\times 10^{-x}\rfloor$. – Dingus Jun 25 at 0:22

## Code-challenge: Guess my number

### The challenge

You have a number from 1 to 10 in mind, and your program should ask questions to find out which number. These questions can be any questions, the program only has to find out the number as fast as possible.

Your program should ask a question, such as "Is the number a prime?", and the user must answer either y or n (yes or no). Ask questions until you know the number.

### The scoring

To calculate the score, you need to take the sum of the question count for each number. For example, if you need 1 question to find the number 1, 2 questions to find the number 2, and so on, the score is 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 6 + 7 + 8 + 9 + 10, so the score is 55.

Important note: the question count for a specific number must always be the same. For example, if you need 4 questions to find out the number 10, then you have to ask always 4 questions to find out the number 10, otherwise it is impossible to calculate the score.

• boooring. The Huffman tree for a uniform set is any perfectly balanced tree. The question asks us to perform a binary search on the usr device. Is the number greater than 5? Is the number greater than 2? Is the number greater than 1? Hey' I think it's 1. – John Dvorak Jan 2 '14 at 11:49
• Maybe if this were a pop-contest and the goal was to make the most original set of questions while still keeping the score at its theoretical minimum. – John Dvorak Jan 3 '14 at 5:28

Bovine Ignorance

I'm curious about code which still works after being mangled by figlet, toilet, cowsay et al, but I'm not sure whether this in any way sane.

What I'm toying with is a challenge in which a participant may submit any program in any language. It should be possible to use this program's source code as input to cowsay or whatever, and the result should be another valid program in any language, which still does a similar thing. For instance, the following bf program prints Hello world! with no newline:

+++++ +++++
[
> +++++ ++
> +++++ +++++
> +++
> +
<<<< -
]
> ++ .
> + .
+++++ ++ .
.
+++ .
> ++ .
<< +++++ +++++ +++++ .
> .
+++ .
----- - .
----- --- .
> + .
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++


Running cat ./prog.bf | cowsay -e .. -T $'>.' yields the following output:  _________________________________________ / +++++ +++++ [ > +++++ ++ > +++++ +++++ \ | > +++ > + <<<< - ] > ++ . > + . +++++ | | ++ . . +++ . > ++ . << +++++ +++++ | | +++++ . > . +++ . ----- - . ----- --- . | | > + . | | +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ | \ ++ / ----------------------------------------- \ ^__^ \ (..)\_______ (__)\ )\/\ >. ||----w | || ||  Which is itself a valid bf program which prints Hello world!!!, followed by a newline. The problem with using bf here is that it ignores most of the cow, making this a bit too easy. The problem with using any other language is that it doesn't ignore most of the cow, making this far too difficult. Is there a sensible middle ground I could pick for this? I don't think it's impossible, I'm fairly sure you can exploit cowsay's behavior on one-liners to produce valid svgs, but I'm not sure how best to pose this challenge. Any ideas? • I could not think of any language that falls in the middle ground. Even brainfuck is affected by the -----------------------------------------..>.---- inserted by cowsay. Most languages have strong parsing rules that would not cope with being post-processed by cowsay. The few exceptions for this will be either completely unaffected or badly affected, making the challenge uninteresting. – Victor Stafusa Feb 19 '14 at 12:32 • Actually, you can't transform just any brainfuck program to cowsay-brainfuck. Namely those that can output fewer than three characters cannot be transformed at all. – John Dvorak Feb 19 '14 at 14:52 • @JanDvorak, I was intending to allow competitors to choose the parameters of their calls to cowsay. For the uninitiated, -e controls the string used for eyes and defaults to oo, and -T controls the string used for the tongue, defaulting to  U. This is all yak-shaving, though, and having written this up and read the comments, I suspect that this idea has neither legs, horns nor udders. – ymbirtt Feb 19 '14 at 23:19 • If I could propose a variant that is more feasible, you could do a challenge like "Write a program in your language of choice that draws ASCII art of a cow saying something (does not have to be identical or even similar to the cowsay art). The entire drawing must itself be valid source code that does something other than no-op. Post results of both programs." That gives people more leeway to work around the specific restrictions of their compiler. – Jonathan Van Matre Feb 21 '14 at 23:22 • Ok, I found a language that falls within the middle ground: whitespace. Anyway, this question has a too narrow scope to develop an interesting challenge. – Victor Stafusa Feb 22 '14 at 18:31 • @JonathanVanMatre That would be a subjective validity criterion, and would probably be closed as too broad. – wastl Jul 2 '18 at 13:55 # 99 Bottles of Errors While there are already many versions of "print 99 Bottles of Beer," I thought another one wouldn't hurt. The challenge is fairly simple: print the lyrics to 99 bottles of Beer to STDERR. I don't care how you do it, so long as the entire lyrics show up. An entire program is required, so the following Java program would be invalid (even if it did do the correct thing): System.out.println("99 Bottles of Beer on the Wall, take one down and pass it around...");  ## The scoring: • This challenge is , so shortest code by byte count wins. • If necessary, assume UTF-8 is the character encoding used. ## The rules • All the code must be in one file. • Any language is allowed. • Reading input, whether it is from STDIN, a file, or the web, is not allowed. • This is trivial in some languages (Java), where it reduces to a simple kolmogorov challenge, and impossible in others (those that have no distinct STDERR) – John Dvorak Mar 27 '14 at 7:42 # Create an Identicon Generator The challenge is to create an identicon generator. The identicons must be randomly generated, so we get a new identicon for each key the program receives. You can input a key using std-in or you can use your language's random number generator for the key. In order to make your identicon look reasonably nice, it must generate a picture, then rotate that picture around the bottom right corner, the way this mockup shows: The output must be to a PNG file. Shortest code wins. • Far too broad. As this stands I can create a 1-pixel image whose colour is just the key. I don't think this question will be ready to go until you've found a way to prevent me from making the images differ only in their palette (and to pre-empt, I think that adding a rule "Images may not differ only in their palette" isn't a real fix). – Peter Taylor Mar 28 '14 at 14:50 • If you just ask for "random" images, you'll get images that are either hardly random at all (a solitary pixel in a random location), or completely random (noise). To get something "reasonably nice", you'll have to provide very clear instructions on how to produce these images. I suggest you try creating a few of these yourself, and find a minimal set of rules that produces results that look OK. Include requirements on dimensions (100x100px?), selection of colours (at least 2, not too similar), and drawing method (e.g., "five triangles with random vertices and a minimum area of 20 px²"). – r3mainer Mar 28 '14 at 15:25 • How important is the PNG file output? This will be a challenge in itself for many languages. Would you accept an uncompressed non-interlaced format like PPM? – trichoplax Apr 16 '14 at 9:45 ## Underhand Bejewled Help me to write a game of bejewled, which cannot be lost! ## Bejewled game rules If you ever played bejewled, you can skip this, but for those who did not see it ever: • Playing field of 8*8 grid is filled in with gems of 7 different types randomly • By swapping two adjective stones, your goal is to create a line of at least three same type of stones in the either vertical or horizontal line • If did so, the gems will dissappear, points are added (say 20 points for a matching) and new gems are provided randomly from the top • image related: ## Your challenge Provide me a game which cannot be lost. In other words, the gems falling from the top are not random at all, but are falling in order that there is always at least one possibility to match three gems But, from looking at the code at level of newbie programmer, it should look like that game acts as if it was random ## Output Playable game. As long as it is the grid of 8*8 filled in with 7 different types of "gems" the game is ok. It does not to have killer graphics, neither it does not need to be playable by mouse. (But in that case please make sure you show which "gem" is hovered and then selected) ## Winning criteria This is popularity contest. So highest rated game wins • I think this is too big a task to work well for an underhanded contest. The programs will be way too large for anyone to actually read the source and try to find what's underhanded about it. – Martin Ender Nov 11 '14 at 8:32 • Thats what I was also afraid of. I will either take it as lesson to progress on my programming skill, or abandon the idea completly – Pavel Janicek Nov 11 '14 at 8:38 # Shortest Program that May or May not Terminate: Write a program such that whether or not it terminates depends on the answer to an unsolved question in Computer Science or Mathematics. For example, your program might test the Goldbach conjecture for every N and quit if a counterexample is found, or hunt for odd perfect numbers. Please include an explanation of why your program may or may not terminate! Note: assume infinite memory and stack size, because otherwise they all terminate. Your program must be self contained, take no input, and only use standard libraries. This is Codegolf, so shortest code wins! • What about "unsolvable" problems, e.g. halting problem? Can I take another code as input and terminate if that terminates? Because that other program may or may not terminate, and there's no way to tell. – Martin Ender Nov 20 '14 at 18:03 • The intention was that the program isn't allowed to take input. I'll be more specific. – QuadmasterXLII Nov 20 '14 at 18:50 • Does this differ from this previous question in the sandbox? – trichoplax Nov 20 '14 at 19:34 • (even if not the comments explaining why that one wouldn't work as a question may help Taylor this one) – trichoplax Nov 20 '14 at 19:35 • The intent of this doesn't differ significantly from the question you linked, I searched posted questions but forgot to search the sandbox. – QuadmasterXLII Nov 20 '14 at 19:41 • Infinite memory isn't required. – feersum Nov 20 '14 at 21:46 # Something Else - ASCII Art maker: A text to ASCII art generator maker, the program must input a string and return ASCII art from it. Something like patorjk.com/software/taag/. It has to use the Graffiti font. The winning criteria is the whoever gets the most likes. • Hello! Just a few things to point out: 1) The current spec is very broad. For example, what fonts, how does spacing look, what characters need to be supported... there's a lot more details that need to be included than just "return ASCII art of this text" – Sp3000 Feb 24 '15 at 4:07 • 2) What's the winning criterion? Popularity contest? Code golf? – Sp3000 Feb 24 '15 at 4:08 # Identifying a Sonnet This challenge is about determining if a given file (read-in from stdin) meets the criteria to be a sonnet. You may use any language for this challenge. If your language supports an API to use an online dictionary you may use that API, if your language doesn't then too bad. Additionally, it is preferred if your language is one that can be ran directly from the command line and is a language that has a compiler or interpreter available directly from my distro's repos(Fedora), as I would rather just use a bash script to test the various programs, then test each program manually. # Definition of a Sonnet • Has 14 Lines (lines are denoted as the standard newline on your operating system). • Has a definite rhyme scheme, it will have one of the following rhyme schemes • ABBA ABBA CD CD CD • ABBA ABBA CDE CDE • ABAB ABBA EFEF GG • Iambic Pentameter - consists of alternating stressed, unstressed syllables. This doesn't have to be perfect 100% of the time, just at least 50% of the time. In order for your program to declare a given string a sonnet, it must meet all of the above criteria. ## Additional Notes You do not have to identify the following: • Thought Structure - too intense for a code golf challenge, and too subjective. • Topic - computer lacks context to determine this # Input Input will be read from stdin. This is the string that you will be declaring to be or not to be a sonnet. # Output Your program will output either yes or no for the question: Does this string meet the given requirements to be a sonnet? As this is code golf yes or no can be abbreviated to Y/N. # Winner The solution with fewest number of bytes win that has the highest accuracy ratio for the correct identification of a sonnet. The preference is for higher accuracy rather than brevity of the program. # Test Data and Resources ## What is not a sonnet The following are examples that you program should return false on: • Beowulf • Haiku • Input that doesn't have exactly 14 Lines in it • The text of this question. • The text of just about any other question on StackExchange. • Things that don't have a rhyme scheme. See Below # Not A Sonnet A man got on a boat The boat was leaky and had poor construction For it was made by a one-eyed blind man and his dumb intern As soon as he got out of port at the fort it started to sink eventually, it tanked. And it capsized If only that shipwright wasn't so blind deaf and dumb as microsoft tech support That's not much support at all.  • I think without dictionaries for rhymes and stresses this is probably not a good idea. Of course you can use some sort of accuracy ratio, but then you also need false positives, and you need a lot more examples than the few on the pages you've linked. But if you do this there's no requirement to actually recognise the sonnets by their rhymes and stresses - instead, I'm pretty sure, people will just regex golf the test sets. – Martin Ender Mar 24 '15 at 19:36 • @MartinBüttner I updated the requirements with an accuracy percentage, and added the option to use an API to look up terms from a dictionary. – HSchmale Mar 24 '15 at 19:57 • 1. Test data which only covers one possible output isn't test data. I can write a program which always outputs Y in as little as one byte and it will pass all of the linked "test data", but it comes nowhere near to meeting spec. 2. Unless you specify which rhyme/stress dictionary to use, you can't guarantee that the test data is "correct". – Peter Taylor Mar 24 '15 at 20:20 • @PeterTaylor I added examples of what is not a Sonnet. – HSchmale Mar 24 '15 at 20:32 • I'm not sure how to say this, but it feels as though this task has a lot of individual parts, each of which could be quite tricky. Especiallly detecting rhymes/syllables/stresses, since words can be pronounced/stressed differently based on context. Also if you're using Shakespeare's sonnets I have no idea where to get rhyming and stress dictionaries for Elizabethan English... – Sp3000 Mar 25 '15 at 14:18 • To make this interesting, you'll need some interesting near-misses: non-sonnets that can't be detected by something simple like counting lines or words per line. – xnor Mar 25 '15 at 20:59 • @xnor You mean a file with a that looks like a sonnet but has no rhyme. – HSchmale Mar 25 '15 at 21:04 • Yes, for example. Or, one with rhyme by wrong rhythm. Or, one with nonsense characters that seem to "rhyme". – xnor Mar 25 '15 at 21:06 • @Sp3000 You can just use modern english, or just base it on words that have similar endings. – HSchmale Mar 25 '15 at 21:11 This and this gave me an idea, but I'm not quite sure if this can be done at all, or if it is trivial. If it is, maybe point out how it could be changed to be interesting. # Anti golfing - Write the longest program not repeating any character Well, it's just what the title says. Finally you're allowed to use as much bytes as possible. ## Conditions • The code of the program or function should not use any character that is used in the code before. • Your program should print some sort of result to stdout, or into a file or return a value. You're not allowed to output or return the empty string or only a newline. • Other than that your program might do anything. Read input, print lots of output, or what you can think of, but you have to explain what it does, of course. • Only characters in the ASCII range [32 .. 126] and newlines are allowed, which limits the maximal code length to 96 bytes. • Variable names are only allowed to consist of a single character • String literals or the like are forbidden. They could be used to hold the unused characters (though they would need two " in most languages anyway). • The same rule applies for similar literal constructs like blocks or what else is there in some languages. • Even if the length of a string literal would be used to generate a number, it is forbidden. • Variables can not just be declared and never be used. They have to be reflected in the output somehow. • If you've read and understood the above rules and still found a loophole and used it, you should go and stand in the corner for a while, thinking about what you've done. So all in all, only use characters for actual code that does something generating the output, might it be calculating a value or formatting. And don't put unused characters somewhere in your code as a literal. Numbers are an exception, but I guess it's no problem to use them anyway. I guess you should have a pretty good idea of what would be considered cheating here. Example in awk BEGIN{gsub(a,9);print$j-13+d^c/4*5678%20}


It prints 15.5, score is 42.

It replaces the empty string a with 9 in $0, which is the empty string in the beginning. So $0 becomes 9.

Then it prints the result of 9-13+1/4*5678%20.

($j is $0 (==9), because j is not defined

d^c ist 1, because c and d are not defined)

Please don't invent languages for this ;)

The longest code in bytes wins.

• Are you sure you want to allow ASCII 127? That's the unprintable<DEL> character. The main problem with this challenge is "only use characters for actual code that does something". This is essentially unenforceable, because there may be arbitrarily complicated no-ops in the code. It's also why most code-bowling challenges fail to be popular/interesting. – Martin Ender Sep 14 '15 at 7:32
• Well, I thought about making it a "most votes win" challenge, but I guess that would be unfair for less known users. I don't know what could be done with what you are pointing out. – Cabbie407 Sep 14 '15 at 7:51
• I don't think this is a good candidate for a popularity contest. Popularity contests shouldn't be used as a cop out if the actual spec is a bit vague. They work best for challenges where the actual scoring criterion can be well specified but is more easily judged by humans than machines (e.g. "visually approximate a given image with these constraints..."). – Martin Ender Sep 14 '15 at 7:54
• Yeah, it's hard to formulate the rules for this. But I think it's not always about finding a winner anyway. Thought this might be fun. Resolved the character 127 situation btw.. – Cabbie407 Sep 14 '15 at 7:57
• How could I change that rule? I'm thinking about "only use code that contributes to the generation of the output" – Cabbie407 Sep 14 '15 at 8:02
• How do you define "contribute"? E.g. this GolfScript program prints the length of the block in {...} which is a convenient way to stuff all characters except in '"# in there. Do all those random characters actually contribute? In Slashes everything which isn't an unescaped slash is printed to STDOUT, so as long as I put \/ together, I can put any characters I want there and they'll all contribute. – Martin Ender Sep 14 '15 at 8:07
• Hmm, I thought this would be covered by forbidding string literals.. might think about extending that rule to blocks. Well, I'm not that fluent at esolangs. – Cabbie407 Sep 14 '15 at 8:10
• It's trivial to use all possible 96 bytes. Trust me. If you really want to see the program I'm thinking of, I suppose I could write it, but I'm pretty sure it can be done. – mbomb007 Sep 16 '15 at 18:34
• Yeah, I guess you're right. i have no idea how it would be done, but alright. – Cabbie407 Sep 16 '15 at 20:10
• Not to mention this is pretty much a duplicate of codegolf.stackexchange.com/questions/30159/… – pppery Aug 6 '17 at 12:52

# Linear Time Sorting

It was another slow day at Initech Inc. when a feature request came in:

New Feature: Ability to sort by cash value in the transaction form. But make it a fast one!


Well it looks simple.. but what do the requester mean by fast one? Let's call Jim, from sales he probably knows what's going on.

Jim: Well you know , our Business Inc. contact is very passionate about

programming and computer science! In fact he had this idea that we should

do sorting in how that was called.. linear time?

You: Well you know that's impossible?

Jim: But it was already approved by their cto and all! You need to do something


You and Jim came up with a plan.. nobody will notice if that big of a list isn't sorted enough, right?

Your task is to write a linear time sorting program. It will be scored on accuracy of the sort as compared to list sorted by regular sorting algorithm but it must work on O(N) time in the worst case, where N is length of the input.

Input will be in the form of list of string-double tuples, e.g:

[("aaaa",2.0) , ("aaba",1.0)]


The program should sort on the number value of the tuple, i.e. in the above case the order should be reversed. There may be multiple inputs with the same double values, but no string value is repeated. In the event that two inputs have the same integer value the perfect solution is to keep the order as it is. The double value may be any floating-point value that fits in 8 byte double precision variable. NaNs should be placed at the end of the list.

The score is calculated as number of "bubble sort operations" (switch an element with the next/previous element) needed to achieve perfect output from the output of your algorithm.

# Sandbox Worries

Well I don't know how clear my explanation of challenge was and if it is interesting to the PPCG crowd.

Obviously there is a need for testing program and test cases.

• How big will the test cases be? If you pick a fixed size, the response will be "n passes of bubble sort where n is the size of the largest test". Bam, linear with perfect score. – John Dvorak Apr 11 '16 at 10:12
• @JanDvorak I rephrased the scoring sentence to more reflect what I meant. In that case the score wouldn't be perfect as after just n switches the list wouldn't be the most ordered. EDIT: I think I understood it now. Well I think you can somehow exclude answers like that with some caveats in the rules, like "Your algorithm cannot make any assumtions about length of the input" – Lause Apr 11 '16 at 10:17
• I don't make any assumptions. It sorts every array up until the largest test case correctly and all other arrays partially. – John Dvorak Apr 11 '16 at 10:28
• An algorithm that fares better than n-pass bubble sort is to do a level-n mergesort. If the length exceeds 2^n, sort each [k::len/2^n] subarray separately. – John Dvorak Apr 11 '16 at 10:32
• But then you're making assumptions based on the size of the test cases - if somehow the test cases were changed (but still fitting the rules) to test cases which are much longer (for example you prepared for max 10 element list and you get 100000 element list) your program isn't linear. – Lause Apr 11 '16 at 10:41
• The problem with a spec is that it cannot change once you've posted the challenge, and you can't define "making assumptions based on the size of the test cases". You can't even ban all magic numbers - I can simply use functions merge1 .. merge20 – John Dvorak Apr 11 '16 at 10:47
• It isn't the spec - the way the test cases used to grade the result are constructed is described but do I have to post the test cases (but those used to score) themselves? – Lause Apr 11 '16 at 10:50
• You need to define the test cases, and you can't change them based on the answers (if only because updating the score of every answer would be a nuisance). Maybe you could ask for asymptotic behavior, but that can be surprisingly hard to measure. – John Dvorak Apr 11 '16 at 10:53
• Hidden test cases are a problem as well, because then we can't test the submissions after you're gone. – John Dvorak Apr 11 '16 at 10:55
• The idea was to pregenerate some test cases (undisclosed) and some test cases that are disclosed (for testing purposes during the coding) and then do a cutoff time for the challenge where all the solutions are tested against the undisclosed challenges. Also obviously after the cutoff time the test cases would be disclosed. – Lause Apr 11 '16 at 10:56
• 1. Most real-life data types can be sorted in linear time, so the premise of the question seems badly flawed. 2. "Input will be in the form of list of string-double tuples ... There may be multiple inputs with the same integer values" Huh? Where do the integer values come from? 3. "The double value may be any floating-point value" Where do NaNs sort? – Peter Taylor Apr 11 '16 at 16:00
• 1. The idea is that the data may be the worst case for any algorithm that can achieve linear sorting time 2. It was a typo 3. At the end - I will put it into the question – Lause Apr 11 '16 at 18:36
• Why does the input being worst case make any difference? The solution will still be perfect, so you'll need a tie-breaker to separate every single answer. – Peter Taylor Apr 11 '16 at 21:27

# Alphabetization 101 (popularity contest)

Your task is to use all 52 letters of both the uppercase and lowercase alphabet, ONCE and ONCE only, and make a program.

You are free to use any other ASCII character more than once, or use a letter of the alphabet more than once if it's required for the language to function.

## Meta:

• Not sure if this has been done before.
• Any questions regarding the task?
• Not really meta: Is there any place I can go to (like a chat or something) to post a question about BF? StackOverflow probably isn't suitable. – clismique Apr 17 '16 at 6:48
• Come to our chatroom! :) – Leaky Nun Apr 17 '16 at 6:50
• I would vote to close this as too broad. It's not a particularly interesting restriction per se, and it certainly doesn't make a good question without some restriction on the task to be performed. – Peter Taylor Apr 17 '16 at 14:07
• @PeterTaylor That's why it's a popularity contest, though - it lets the people decide whether the program made is good or not. What WOULD be a good restriction on the task? – clismique Apr 18 '16 at 1:40
• The popularity-contest tag is not an excuse for a broad challenge. "Write a program that does anything..." is pretty much the definition of "too broad", regardless of any source code restriction put on the program. So at least you should choose a specific task. Could be anything really, but if it relates to the restriction it might be more interesting (e.g. a pangram checker). Even so, I agree with Peter that the restriction isn't particularly interesting. There are tons of languages where it's trivial to avoid unwanted letters and then include the remaining ones in a string or comment. – Martin Ender Apr 21 '16 at 7:04

# Why did I come to Sandbox?

I have a very specific challenge, and I wanted to see if it was too specific.

The challenge is to output "Valdosta ACM" using the shortest number of characters with the BrainF**k programming language.

I've noticed it isn't the norm to specify a programming language on this domain, so I've come here to get feedback on whether or not this is acceptable.

# Introduction

As a challenge to the members of my local Association for Computing Machinery(ACM) chapter, I asked them to produce the shortest Brainf**k code that would output "Valdosta ACM".

This was a very fun challenge for all of our members, and we got very competitive! I was impressed with the solutions turned in, but I wondered if it was possible to beat our best solution. Surely it's possible, but who could do it?

# Challenge

Output the string "Valdosta ACM".

Stipulations:

• Use only the Brainf**k programming language (you can test your code here)

• No input can be accepted by your program

• The space in the string must be ASCII character #032.

These are the ASCII values of each character, as they appear in the string, for convenience:

 086 097 108 100 111 115 116 097 032 065 067 077


The winner is determined by the shortest code, by character count.

# Example Input and Output

### Input:

NO input is allowed

### Output:

Valdosta ACM

• Welcome to Programming Puzzles & Code Golf! Thanks for using the Sandbox. :) A few things to note: 1.) Generally we discourage language-specific challenges, 2.) typically code golf is scored by bytes rather than characters, and 3.) printing a fixed string like this would be insufficiently different from the Hello, World! challenge to avoid it being closed as a duplicate. – Alex A. Apr 25 '16 at 3:38
• Thanks Alex! Since I want to compare the results of my local competition with the results of the challenge here, is there anything I could change about the challenge to make it acceptable? I don't see a way to do this, but I was so excited about seeing if anyone here could do better than our coders. And thanks for the warm welcome! :) – Matt C Apr 25 '16 at 3:48
• You could look at Brainf**k solutions to other challenges (like this one), and see if the techniques used there can help you improve your solution. – ugoren Apr 25 '16 at 7:09
• We also have a tips question that may be of interest. – trichoplax Apr 26 '16 at 6:30
• Although this particular challenge is probably too similar to "Hello, World!" (as Alex pointed out), if you had a different challenge that you wanted to see solutions for in a specific language, you can still post it but just allow all languages to compete. If you don't see solutions in your specific language you can post a bounty for that language to encourage it. – trichoplax Apr 26 '16 at 6:33

## Cops and robbers : Programmers/Hackers

• This challenge is quite different from my previous challenges. This challenge is an endless competition between robbers and cops, which are respectively hackers and programmers. One of them will ever win!!!

• This will evolve to code de/obfuscating when it gets to the higher stages: a skillful programmer who is struggling to save his program from a sourcecode-mangling attempted by a cunning "robber" who tries to impose his existence by patching his name instead of the name of the "programmer" in the output console without changing anything else in the code. The story begins this way:

• Programmer is at the point of executing his recently made C code, so he included this trivial line to show off:

C (1)

    printf("[Programmer's username]")


After executing this program programmer saw this on the screen:

[Robber's username]


which indicates the presence of some evil code at the compiler level that compromises his code, which follows:

Matlab (2)/parser

      a=findstr(code,'printf(''[Programmer's username]'')'); if a code(a:20)='printf(''[Robber's username]'')';end


The programmer cannot modify the counter-program in the compiler, so he must rather change the program content to escape the twiddling:

PHP (3)

      $a='[programmer's username]';echo$a;


The score is now 3, which is the number of steps from the beginning. The current user would win only if the hacker did not figure out something like:

PHP/Regex(pcre flavor) (4)

      $code=ereg_replace("(\$\w)\='programmer';(.*?);echo\s\1","\1\='robber';\2;echo\s\1",$code)  Since the solution above does not satisfy the rules (see the bottom of this question), the score stays unchanged, and the programmer can make a counter example, and take out the score from last submitter with a penalty on his score equivalent of how much he earned in the earlier level, where the counter example can be something as: PHP (4) $a='programmer';$b=$a;$a='unrelated';echo$a;


Or he can adjust his program in higher scale to escape all the regex-trapping in a superior range, So the cycle goes on until no post can be added and the last submitter before the end of June is declared a potential winner meanwhile.

The hacker can also fix his regex and regain his score, so the recent scoring will be abrogated from programmer.

Perl/dynamic-regex (4)

local @a=('');

sub check{
if (grep {$_ eq @_[1]} @a) {push @a,@_[0]; } elsif (grep {$_ eq @_[0]} @a)   {
my @del_indexes = grep { @a[$_] eq @_[0] } 0..$#a;
foreach $item (@del_indexes) { splice (@a,$item,1);
}
}
return 1;
}

sub actor{
if (grep {$_ eq @_[0]} @a) {return "print robber";} else {return "print ".@_[0];} } sub initiate{ push(@a,@_[0]); return 1; }$code =~ s/(((\w+)\="programmer"(??{initiate($3);}))|(print\s(\w+))|((\w+)\=(\w+)(?{check(($7),($8));})(?1)))/print($2);actor($5)/pegmx;  As you can see this Perl program prints b in the first case because the variable b is compromised after the first assignment, but in the second case the regex modifies the output because d receives the target-string transitively. Let's just stop here and not mess the fun (of course, if there will be some). ## Scoring and rules How is the score counted ? • Any hacker/programmer is scored for his code as the actual level L the game is on. • A partial dynamic regex within the core of the program is scored L + (2^L)/log(length of program + length of characters which do not belong to the regex)), where the log is base 2. For the second example of level (4) the length of the compacted program is 480, and the length of regex is 136, so the score is 4+2^4/log2(480+480-136) ~= 4+16/9.6 • A fully functional regex as in the first example level (4) is scored L + (2^L)/log(length of regex), where the log is base 2, in that case S = 4 + 2^4 / log(91) ~= 4+16/6.5 • Scores are added progressively to submitters, and when a level is surpassed with no regex, it is still open for scores, while the actual winner remains unchanged. • A penalty on a certain-leveled score when the regex/parser is revealed out of rules and the game is regressed to this stage until the issue is fixed, rules are cited below: Rules: • The main rule: the hacker-program must compromise an output to the console, which is the username of the programmer. Any other behavior is unaccepted simply because a string variable of [programmer's username] can be used in other order rather than printing, a counter-example is easy, converting the string to integer then use it for arithmetic calculations that harms the main program once intentionally modified. • Also one of the following factors declared by any counter-example bans the targeted flawed regex/parser as non rule-complying: • The regex/parser prints anything other than a chosen string preferably set as the username of the robber. • The regex/parser generates a program which does not compile. • The regex/parser does not print anything, or compromises a segment of code that is needed for tasks other than printing . • The variable which stores the program is named code by default, also you may assume that is one-liner, and any non-significant spaces are omitted, and that it is fully working by default. • The regex/parser deals with one variant of one code proportion in a comprehensive way, i.e. if a print function is used, that encompasses all printing functions in all languages puts,disp,..etc. Also, code separators can be unified to one characterL either , or ; or a significant space needlessly of enumerating all keywords/syntaxes, this is not a contest about a working code in a specific programming language. • To prevent endless program/regex loops let's just not making a jokey sequence as a='programmer';print a / /(\w)\='programmer';print\s\1/ / a='programmer';b=a;print b / /(\w)\='programmer';(\w)\=\1;print\s\2/ because the first person who makes a regex/parser which palliates to a same replicated idea will take out all attributed scores to this idea from their owners, so any anaphoric sequences like this in addition that they are set to same level, they are unneeded. • Any language that uses pointers/addresses/classes like C++ are welcome, as long as they help to evade the hacker. • Please, for the love of god, spell things correctly. In the first bit alone I spotted a ton of spelling mistakes without even looking for them. Also, that whole first list is... basically impossible to understand, at least for me. Maybe use full sentences? – Fund Monica's Lawsuit May 10 '16 at 21:29 • Have you seen our cops-and-robbers challenges? It sounds like that is what you are trying to do here. That said, there are a couple of problems with the spec: Defining what parts of the language counts as a "partial regex" or "full regex" is really tough, especially when we get into esoteric languages. – Nathan Merrill May 10 '16 at 21:36 • Could you add a short summary to the post? I don't understand what the actual task here is. Is this a cops-and-robbers or answer-chaining challenge, or something entirely different? – Zgarb May 10 '16 at 21:36 • i will see what cops and robbers is – Abr001am May 10 '16 at 21:39 • @NathanMerrill this is not a code golf so i dont see the point of introducing esolangs here – Abr001am May 10 '16 at 22:28 • @Agawa001 Esoteric languages are still useful outside of golfing. You can use them to make it tough for regexes to match. – Nathan Merrill May 10 '16 at 23:06 • The introduction is very long and after reading it I have no idea what the task is. I would have to vote to close this as "Unclear what you're asking" in its current state. – Peter Taylor May 11 '16 at 7:45 • So what's the core mechanic? Is this an answer-chaining question where answers must alternate programmer and hacker? But if the programmer can change language at will, how can the hacker hope to win? – Peter Taylor May 12 '16 at 12:06 • @PeterTaylor yes it is answer chaining but the last submitter can post two consecutive answers and be the robber and cop themselves, the programmer change his code, hacker changes his regex taken consideration of all last regex/parsers. – Abr001am May 12 '16 at 16:13 • I have no idea what this challenge is supposed to be. The very little explanation of the concept is muddled by spelling and grammar issues. Please, learn English spelling and grammar before trying to write a challenge. – Mego May 13 '16 at 5:18 • @PeterTaylor refer at the 4th rule, procedures which accomplishes a specific task in different languages are dealt as one thing, this is not a challenge about checking language-syntaxes, when a programmer changes language, consider all previous regex/parsers changed to trap same functionnalities of previous code on the new language. – Abr001am May 28 '16 at 11:37 ## Challenge Write a program that takes an numerical input n and outputs the nth number that is not a perfect square. ## Rules This is , so least bytes wins. • What's the maximum expected input? Does it expect 0? How do we handle 0? Is there a requirement on the efficiency for large inputs? Also give some example inputs and outputs. – Patrick Roberts Jun 17 '16 at 20:19 • Here's some test cases I just generated: 1->2,2->3,3->5,4->6,5->7,6->8,7->10,8->11,9->12,10->13,11->14,12->15,13->17,14->18,15->19,16->20,17->21,18->22,19->23,20->24,21->26,22->27,23->28,24->29,25->30,26->31,27->32,28->33,29->34,30->35,31->37,32->38,33->39,34->40,35->41,36->42,37->43,38->44,39->45,40->46,41->47,42->48,43->50,44->51,45->52,46->53,47->54,48->55,49->56,50->57,51->58,52->59,53->60,54->61,55->62,56->63,57->65,58->66,59->67,60->68,61->69,62->70,63->71,64->72,65->73,66->74,67->75,68->76,69->77,70->78,71->79,72->80 Is this the function you expect? – Patrick Roberts Jun 17 '16 at 20:41 • Yes, yes it is. – weatherman115 Jun 17 '16 at 20:42 • Can you address my other questions please? Namely, the largest expected input and how to handle input of 0. – Patrick Roberts Jun 17 '16 at 20:43 # Generate all variations of a string with every combination of upper and lower case for each vowel but leaving consonants and order of letters unchanged. This is a simplified analog of a problem I've thought about a few times over the years based around variant spellings in different spoken languages. Input is a text string. Output is an array of all variations of the text string. A "variation" means the same letters in the same order but for each vowel letter in the string we generate a version of that string with the vowel in uppercase and the vowel in lowercase. No variation should be included more than once. No legal variation may be omitted. # Example ## Input codegolf ## Output • codegolf • codegOlf • codEgolf • codEgOlf • cOdegolf • cOdegOlf • cOdEgolf • cOdEgOlf The winner shall be the most elegant as voted by the community. "Elegant" includes that the algorithm should be optimal in terms of Big O notation, should be concise, should be idiomatic making good use of available features of the implementation language. Length of code characters or bytes is not relevant. Programming language is open. • "most elegant as voted by the community." I doubt many answers to such a challenge will be deemed elegant. – Fatalize Jun 23 '16 at 13:01 • Really? Anything to suggest instead? Just "best" is usually no good for Stack Exchange... – hippietrail Jun 23 '16 at 13:22 • Code golf version of this challenge: codegolf.stackexchange.com/q/80995/8478. That said, I don't think "most elegant" makes a good popularity contest and is very likely to be downvoted and closed almost instantly. If you're looking for elegant solutions, this might not be the right community in the first place though. You could write your own solution and post it on Code Revew to ask for improvements. We generally require objective winning criteria for our challenges, and popularity contests are in a weird place where you need to come up with something really good for it to be accepted. – Martin Ender Jun 23 '16 at 13:30 • Hmm well OK whatever. – hippietrail Jun 24 '16 at 11:55 # Make a Fork Bomb code-golf under construction, please constructively (no pun intended) criticize Create a program which forks itself at twice and exits, or forks itself once and idles. Whether it continues forever or exits is your choice. Forks can be OS forks or simply a command to relaunch the program. ## Rules • No spoon bombs allowed, please. • Don't make any assumptions about the location of the program. # Bash, 10 chars ./$0|./\$0&


Acts as a standard punching bag for other solutions.

# Microsoft Windows Batch file, 5 chars

 %0|%0


Anybody who beats this one gets a million internet points. (and maybe a bounty)

• I assume that the downvote is because someone considers that this violates our policy on malicious code. I think it's borderline, but if it's on the right side of the border then the question has other issues. 1. Why fork itself at least twice? Surely forking once is enough for a fork bomb? 2. Define "OS forks" in a way which doesn't rely on the OS being POSIX. Or, better, remove that requirement: it seems to me to limit the languages permitted more than necessary for no benefit. 3. What's a spoon bomb? Google is not being helpful. – Peter Taylor Jul 14 '16 at 13:49
• @PeterTaylor 1. the chat said it was fine 2. If you only fork once and exit, you have a constant amount of processes 3. Good idea. Any tips for windows forks? 4. it's a joke – noɥʇʎԀʎzɐɹƆ Jul 14 '16 at 16:38
• I'm downvoting because I think it's close enough to malicious. A fork bomb can hang a computer. – mbomb007 Jul 22 '16 at 19:27

# 2 Pass Hello world

You've heard about this fancy new programming language, but you're not sure you understand it perfectly. So you want to go over a new "Hello world" tutorial again.

How boring!

Instead you have a good idea, using your knowledge of the first programming language to create a "Hello world" program in the second programming language.

Exemple:

console.log('print "Hello world"');


Evaluated in javascript output:

print "Hello world"


Which, evaluated in python 2.X output:

"Hello world"


Nice, but, can it be shorter?

• We have a tag for multi-language challenges, polyglot. – Rɪᴋᴇʀ May 4 '16 at 14:06
• Pyth: \H (Guess what the second language is) – Leaky Nun May 4 '16 at 14:08
• Maybe add a scoring mechanism by how many languages it works in? e.g. console.log('print("puts\'Hello, World!\'")') would score len(submission)/num_languages_it_works_in? – Rɪᴋᴇʀ May 4 '16 at 14:09
• Then the submission above would score 0. – Leaky Nun May 4 '16 at 14:09
• (To OP) Maybe you would need to add some more rules – Leaky Nun May 4 '16 at 14:11
• @KennyLau no? 2/2 = 1 – Rɪᴋᴇʀ May 4 '16 at 14:11
• @EᴀsᴛᴇʀʟʏIʀᴋ It can be fed into itself for one more pass... – Leaky Nun May 4 '16 at 14:12
• I didn't want to add any recursive mechanism, because the end goal should be to display "Hello world" but a more than 2 language is a great idea. – nobe4 May 4 '16 at 14:15
• I don't see how you will be able to come up with a good scoring system for this. Using two esolangs / two times the same esolang will result in 1/2 bytes answers right away. – Fatalize May 4 '16 at 14:16
• @KennyLau, what rules do you generally add to a incomplete challenge? we thought adding a time/memory limit for the execution, but seems irrelevant... – nobe4 May 4 '16 at 14:17
• This is really closely related to several other challenges we've had on the site, such as this one and this one. You'll need to be very careful to not make it a duplicate. – AdmBorkBork May 4 '16 at 14:22
• Also this one, which is practically a duplicate, just with numbers instead of "Hello, world." – AdmBorkBork May 4 '16 at 14:26
• Yeah, I haven't seen all this, I guess I'll start searching for another idea instead ;) – nobe4 May 4 '16 at 14:29
• Also, welcome to PPCG! (I forgot to mention that earlier). Hope you enjoy yourself here! – AdmBorkBork May 4 '16 at 14:36

# Return True to Win - Counter javascriptcode-golf

Original credit goes to this site, which you should all check out

Write the shortest javascript code to pass as parameter f to function counter such that it returns true:

function counter(f) {
var a = f(), b = f();
return a() == 1 && a() == 2 && a() == 3
&& b() == 1 && b() == 2;
}


I'm considering also making this a series with all the rest of the challenges on the site, where each one gets harder

• Given the lack of a terms of use page on the site, the code on that site is copyrighted, with no provisions for reproduction. This is copyright violation. – Mego Aug 9 '16 at 6:00
• In addition to Mego's note regarding copyright, language-specific challenges are not typically well-received by the community. – Alex A. Aug 9 '16 at 18:18

# Stump The Golfing Languages

This is the seed of an idea. I'm unclear on the details that might make it work.

I want people to submit answers in the form of a program in a "normal" language (defined how?), such that reproducing its functionality in a golfing language isn't much smaller. That is, I want to find the algorithms that Jelly and Pyth and Matl and such are not optimized for.

I would appreciate suggestions on how to make this work. Maybe cops and robbers? Maybe each entry just contains two programs, and comments are given to help golf the smaller one?

• The only language that could possibly win is mathematica – Destructible Lemon Aug 23 '16 at 1:52
• – Dennis Aug 23 '16 at 1:53
• It's very easy to come up with boring examples e.g. print this exact trace, reproduce the output of this random number generator, etc. I don't see any way to get interesting answers. – feersum Aug 23 '16 at 6:31
• @feersum I'd probably disqualify errors and crashes and stacktrace outputs and such, and maybe all built-in non-trivial algorithms. Thanks for pointing those out. – Sparr Aug 24 '16 at 7:26
• @DestructibleWatermelon you don't have to beat the golfing language to win. The winning entry will probably still have a shorter Jelly solution than Python (or whatever). – Sparr Aug 24 '16 at 7:27
• I don't know of any golfing languages where creating a simple webserver is possible. All this would be is finding a task that isn't normally required for when doing code-golf – Blue Aug 24 '16 at 14:16
• I'm thinking of restricting it to algorithms and output, not stuff like network and file access. – Sparr Aug 24 '16 at 22:11

# Draw "Stack Exchange"

Stack Exchange has many site (159) and It has a logotype too. Anyway, In this challenge you'll need to draw Stack Exchange in the most shortest way.

This is a code-golf. challenge.

## Rules

1. Have fun!
2. You've to draw Stack Exchange, you can't use Paint or something like that, you can't use libraries.
• Challenges that start with "Most creative" are almost certainly guaranteed to not generate creative answers (or any answers for that matter) – Fatalize Sep 8 '16 at 13:47
• @Fatalize I changed the challenge. – Rizze Sep 8 '16 at 13:54
• Now there is basically no interesting solution possible to the challenge, because there is no patterns in Stack Exchange. So all shortest solutions will to print that string directly or a compressed version of it. – Fatalize Sep 8 '16 at 13:58

## 99 selttob fo reeb no eht llaw popularity-conteststring

I teb ev'uoy lla draeh tuoba eht doog 'lo 99 selttob fo reeb no eht llaw. Llew ti os sneppah taht I emoc morf na evitanretla esrevinu - eht esrevinu erehw ew etirw gnihtyreve ni esrever! Ew peek eht snoitisop fo lanigiro hguoht. Siht osla snaem reporp noitazilatipac fo tsrif (ekil rettel ni siht txet). Ruoy egnellahc si ot etirw a margorp taht stuptuo eht lausu 99 selttob fo reeb no eht llaw, tub ni esrever (ni ruo egaugnal uoy dluow llac ti 99 bottles of beer on the wall). Siht si a ytiralupop tsetnoc, os teg evitaerc dna yrt ot sserpmi eht dworc. Doog kcul!

I bet you've all heard about the good ol' 99 bottles of beer on the wall. Well it so happens that I come from an alternative universe - the universe where we write everything in reverse! We keep the positions of original though. This also means proper capitalization of first letter(like in this text). Your challenge is to write a program that outputs the usual 99 bottles of beer on the wall, but in reverse (in our language you would call it 99 selttob fo reeb no eht llaw). This is a popularity contest, so get creative and try to impress the crowd. Good luck!

Elpmas fo derised tuptuo:

Sample of desired output:

99 selttob fo reeb no eht llaw, 99 selttob fo reeb. Ekat eno nwod dna ssap ti dnuora, 89 selttob fo reeb no eht llaw.

89 selttob fo reeb no eht llaw, 89 selttob fo reeb. Ekat eno nwod dna ssap ti dnuora, 79 selttob fo reeb no eht llaw.

...

1 elttob fo reeb no eht llaw, 1 elttob fo reeb. Ekat eno nwod dna ssap ti dnuora, on erom selttob fo reeb no eht llaw.

On erom selttob fo reeb no eht llaw, on erom selttob fo reeb. Og ot eht erots dna yub emos erom, 99 selttob fo reeb no eht llaw.

• There's no need for the reversed text in the description - it distracts the viewer from the challenge at hand. – clismique Oct 21 '16 at 12:06
• @Qwerp-Derp I wanted to make this a bit more "unique" and "immersing", so I thought about giving the reversed description(I like it). I also included original text(although in spoilers), but I was also wondering about distracting readers. Do you have some other idea on how to keep both versions without making it look obscure? – MatthewRock Oct 21 '16 at 12:10
• 1. This should not be a popularity-contest. 2. It's fundamentally a duplicate of codegolf.stackexchange.com/q/64198/194 . 3. If you're going to muck around with the question text, write a program that mucks it around correctly. "elpmaS" doesn't follow the specified transformation rule. – Peter Taylor Oct 21 '16 at 12:34
• @PeterTaylor 1. why not? 2. It's not. You can't simply reverse, and counting is a bit different. – MatthewRock Oct 21 '16 at 13:24
• Do X creatively popularity contests have fallen out of scope. This will get closed if posted on main. – Dennis Oct 21 '16 at 13:46
• @Dennis Damn, too bad. I guess I won't be posting it then, it's boring "shortest code". – MatthewRock Oct 21 '16 at 14:16
• What does this add to the original '99 bottles of beer on the wall'? – 0WJYxW9FMN Oct 21 '16 at 20:54
• This sandbox post has had little activity in a while and little positive reception from the community. Please improve / edit it or delete it to help us clean up the sandbox. – programmer5000 Jun 9 '17 at 14:08

# Best n out of 2n - 1

### Challenge:

This one should be relatively simple. Output this exact text:

Best [n] out of [2n - 1].


given n as an input.

### Input:

Just the integer n, can be from stdin or as an argument. n will always be greater than 0.

### Output:

The exact text above. Trailing spaces/newlines are allowed.

### Rules:

This is , so shortest code in bytes wins. Standard loopholes are forbidden.

### Meta:

Is this too simple? What other tags should be included, ?

• Seems like a dupe of 2spooky4me, just with a different operator. – Geobits Nov 1 '16 at 17:52
• Your wording specifies "this exact text" while I think your intent is "Best 5 out of 9." or the like. – AdmBorkBork Nov 1 '16 at 17:53
• @Geobits Aha, I knew I remembered a similar challenge. Just forgot the exact name, so I thought maybe I was just imagining things after I tried to find it. My bad. – Yodle Nov 1 '16 at 17:55

# Google Home / Amazon Echo - Turing complete?

Your challenge is to try to make a turing machine based on Google Home and Amazon Echo, see this video.

You must describe how to set up the machine, and how to give it input.

You must also describe a program for integer addition. It should compute 1+1 to be 2, 200+55 = 255, 200+56 = 0, and so on for all other combinations of 2 8-bit integers.

• It's basically not possible... – TuxCrafting Dec 2 '16 at 19:52
• VTC as unclear and too broad. What are you even expecting as an answer? – Rɪᴋᴇʀ Dec 2 '16 at 19:52
• @EasterlyIrk A set of commands that send the 2 computers into infinite loop, reading commands endlessly from a list of commands for the other to run, eventually processing a computer program and finally calculating the answer to the universe. – SoniEx2 Dec 2 '16 at 20:14
• @TùxCräftîñg Why not? I mean other than that we have yet to prove their turing-completeness. – SoniEx2 Dec 2 '16 at 20:14
• @SoniEx2 so only 1 of each computer? And what defines a command? – Rɪᴋᴇʀ Dec 2 '16 at 20:16
• @EasterlyIrk A command is anything that starts with "Hey google" or "Alexa" and triggers a successful response on either of the computers. – SoniEx2 Dec 2 '16 at 20:19
• Are we allowed to program the Echo and Google device? If so this is trivial. If we're supposed to construct a sentence that winds up having the devices compute using existing services like the calendar in the video, there are plenty of web sites that can process a variety of languages and read back the solution. Echo has basic math built in. – wyldstallyns Dec 2 '16 at 21:09
• I really hope this can be tweaked into a challenge because the youtubes would be awesome. – wyldstallyns Dec 2 '16 at 21:12
• @wyldstallyns tbh I have no idea what I'm doing... But yes, you're allowed to program both of them. – SoniEx2 Dec 2 '16 at 22:51
• A question should ideally be self-contained. In this case the APIs for Google Home (whatever that is) and Amazon Echo (whatever that is) probably won't fit in the question, but an overview and links to the APIs would. – Peter Taylor Dec 2 '16 at 23:03
• @PeterTaylor This isn't a matter of APIs. This is a matter of voice commands. – SoniEx2 Dec 3 '16 at 0:19

# Prelude:

Joke languages are allowed.
Submissions' scores will vary depending on whether they'll be made in a joke language, golfing language or a Turing complete language, don't worry if your score is high just because you chose a TC language.
That being said, let's get right into the challenge...

# Challenge:

Make a program as close as possible to the language name and document what it does in the description.

# Scoring/rules:

(will assume a simple language I made up, called Printr that has only a print() command that can take a argument to print but doesn't have to)

• Submissions that contain more than a 1/2 of whole language name in a string (ex. print("Printr")) are banned.
• Submissions must not throw any errors/exceptions/warnings (writing to an error stream is okay though).
• +1 for every char away from language's name (ex. print("r") is 4 chars away, (""), +4 points)
• Submissions need to contain (at least once) the language name "in a row" excluding nonalphanumeric characters and ignoring case (ex. print(" *@)!R") is okay, print("lolz R") is not okay)
• Duplicates of the name will be counted as other characters (ex. print("r") print("r") is still 4+1 [space]+10=15).

By looking as close as the language I mean having the least score (since scoring is based on other characters than the language name itself.

# Example:

## Printr, score 4:

print("r")

This program prints "r" then quits.

• is it allowed to throw an error? – FlipTack Dec 18 '16 at 14:00
• @Flp.Tkc, good question, errors shouldn't be allowed (syntax error be like). – n4melyh4xor Dec 18 '16 at 14:07
• What about a warning to STDERR? Stray error output is allowed by default on meta... – FlipTack Dec 18 '16 at 14:19
• @Flp.Tkc, should be okay. – n4melyh4xor Dec 18 '16 at 14:24
• ><>, in ><>, score 0, infinite loops. – redstarcoder Dec 18 '16 at 15:56
• or actually if we're excluding non-alphanumeric characters, this could also be golfed down to > or empty depending on if outputting "something smells fishy..." is a valid program. – redstarcoder Dec 18 '16 at 16:00
• in brainfuck you can just write brainfuck and it won't do anything... – FlipTack Dec 19 '16 at 17:31

A simple challenge: Shortest program that takes the longest to compile.

• What's the scoring requirement (i.e. how will programs be scored)? Who's machine will this be run on? – clismique Feb 11 '17 at 1:43
• It's too broad of a challenge; are infinite loops allowed? To reiterate what Qwerp-Derp said, how will it be scored? Longest to compile -- what if it's an interpreted language? – user42649 Feb 11 '17 at 1:47
• @AlexL.: languages without a compiler would be excluded. – jmoreno Feb 11 '17 at 1:57
• I still believe this is not a good challenge because it is unclear what you are asking and it is too broad. – user42649 Feb 11 '17 at 2:01

# Make a Simple GUI application

I have made a simple glade layout. The chalenge is to remake it in as few bytes as possible.

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!-- Generated with glade 3.20.0 -->
<interface>
<requires lib="gtk+" version="3.20"/>
<object class="GtkApplicationWindow">
<property name="can_focus">False</property>
<property name="title" translatable="yes">Remake me!</property>
<child>
<object class="GtkBox">
<property name="visible">True</property>
<property name="can_focus">False</property>
<property name="orientation">vertical</property>
<child>
<object class="GtkButton">
<property name="label" translatable="yes">hello</property>
<property name="visible">True</property>
<property name="can_focus">True</property>
</object>
<packing>
<property name="expand">False</property>
<property name="fill">True</property>
<property name="position">0</property>
</packing>
</child>
<child>
<object class="GtkLabel">
<property name="visible">True</property>
<property name="can_focus">False</property>
<property name="label" translatable="yes">world</property>
</object>
<packing>
<property name="expand">False</property>
<property name="fill">True</property>
<property name="position">1</property>
</packing>
</child>
</object>
</child>
<child>
<placeholder/>
</child>
</object>
</interface>

• This probably doesn't break any rules, but it also doesn't seem that fun. It would be preferable if it was a more substantial task than simply golfing the code you already wrote. – Ad Hoc Garf Hunter Feb 18 '17 at 2:09