We (Stack Exchange Inc.) think that this is a really great initiative, and we want to support it by offering a reward: We'd like to give and iPad 2 to a user who goes through great lengths to make codegolf.se more awesome™.
The question that remains is: Who should get it? How do we decide who deserves this prize?
Should it go to a great puzzle? A great solution? A consistenly great puzzle maker? A consistently great solver? A combination of those?
We need your help to decide this. We really want to encourage great puzzles and awesome answers, and you, the regular users of the site, are in the best position to tell us who would deserve it.
Go ahead and offer your thoughts!
Update: We've decided that while (as everyone noticed) coming up with clear hard rules is pretty hard, by many metrics Keith Randall has done a great deal for the site, so we've picked him. Expect an email, Keith :)
And (somewhat of a second price) as a thank you to George Edison for essentially creating a plugin that caters to the specialty of this site, we'll send him on a shopping spree in the Stack Exchange swag store.
Thanks, you two, and everyone else!