40
votes
Definite policy about duplicate answers
Allow duplicate answers
I think we shouldn't take action against duplicate submissions, even when the code is identical. We should assume good faith: the second submitter almost surely came up with ...
- 144k
34
votes
Accepted
Can we revive The Programming Language Quiz?
Revive it, with a different task
I would enjoy a Programming Language Quiz Mark II. To keep things interesting, the task should be different.
I suggest a task involving simple integer math, which ...
- 38k
16
votes
Should "Code the Huffman!" remain closed as a duplicate of a very old question?
TL;DR: They are duplicates. Close the old one.
First, I'd like to clarify that I do think the questions are duplicates. I agree with Peter that a difference in the output format counts as a "minor ...
- 196k
16
votes
Accepted
Reposts of answer-chaining challenges
Yes, under specific circumstances:
I think that DJMcMayhem made some really good points as to why we don't like duplicates. I'll address the two he felt were still relevant to answer-chaining:
A ...
- 14.4k
15
votes
Is the "duplicate" system too harsh?
To respond specifically to your example: according to your profile, you joined the site about six weeks ago. This is probably only the first or second dupe of that question you've seen. I've seen ...
- 43.1k
15
votes
Reposts of answer-chaining challenges
Yes, but the reposting of a challenge must be voted on
Instead of having a set time limit and max number of reposts, we could have a thread similar to the sandbox where there could be "repost ...
- 39.9k
15
votes
When can challenges be reused?
Challenges should never be reused.
If a challenge has been posted in the past and you think it would be fun to participate in it, participate in the existing challenge. Don't repost an old challenge ...
- 24.6k
15
votes
Should we rehash Add A Language To A Polyglot?
I was the original poster of the original challenge, and have had some thoughts about what I'd change if doing it again. (Note: these are only thoughts, not directives or requirements, and it's quite ...
- 11
15
votes
Could a new "Is it a power of 2?" question escape being closed as a duplicate?
If a new "Powers of 2" question is allowed to stay open, "Completely even" should still be left open.
Although in many golfing languages an answer to both questions is the same ...
- 11.5k
14
votes
Accepted
Are these questions about balanced parentheses really duplicates?
I don't think either one should be closed.
The other one includes a ton of bonuses. While I don't think they are a great idea, they significantly change the challenge. Also, without the bonuses, the ...
- 196k
12
votes
Is fibtraction a dupe?
Is the question a dupe?
Yes, it is
Our standard for whether one question duplicates another is: can answers from one question be copied with minor modifications and be competitive?
I'm not going to ...
- 43.1k
11
votes
Accepted
We decided to post a new factorial challenge. Should we close the old one as dupe?
No, leave both challenges open
As Luis Mendo requested in the comment, here is a copy of my statement for voting.
I believe it is not a dupe because the solutions to the existing challenge are not ...
- 73.8k
10
votes
Should we rehash Add A Language To A Polyglot?
I have long supported making a second run. Due to the answer chaining nature I think the challenge would be very interesting if we pushed it in a different path.
However I don't like the proposed ...
Wheat WizardMod
- 96.5k
9
votes
Duplicates with different restrictions or no restrictions
Regarding a general policy
I don't think a general rule on restricted challenges would work very well. It depends a lot on the challenge and the restriction whether it makes a sufficient difference. ...
- 196k
9
votes
Accepted
Which questions should get deleted (and how fast)?
tl;dr: Don't worry about it.
For off-topic posts such as general programming questions, there's no reason to waste your time and delete votes on posts that will already get Roomba'd automatically. ...
- 71.4k
8
votes
Could a new "Is it a power of 2?" question escape being closed as a duplicate?
Yes, a new Powers of 2 question should be allowed to stay open.
- 11.5k
7
votes
Closing as Duplicate on Meta
Close only if they would have the same answers
For the question https://codegolf.meta.stackexchange.com/q/7887/25180, the answers are supposed to be:
Yes, they are drowning us. (But we may want to be ...
- 36.9k
7
votes
Should we close challenges as dupes of closed challenges?
I think this is a special case of a more general question which has come up in the past week in a different guise. I will therefore address the more general question:
What should I do with a ...
- 43.1k
7
votes
Accepted
Is my question a duplicate even though it doesn't impose a requirement that the original one did?
Maybe!
The title of this question is general, so I'll provide a general answer. It applies to the specific challenges mentioned in the question too.
Ask yourself this:
Does it bring something new ...
- 46.2k
6
votes
Accepted
Is it acceptable to rerun an old coding challenge as a new thread?
It Depends
In general, we handle reposting of challenges on a case by case basis. For this particular instance, I would argue that this KOTH challenge is OK to re-run, provided that someone can't ...
- 43.3k
6
votes
Would this potential challenge be a duplicate of an existing one?
Yes, it's too similar
The standard metric we use here for "Is challenge A a duplicate of challenge B?" is "Can answers from B be trivially ported to answer A?". Most of the answers ...
- 49.4k
6
votes
Accepted
Why does Community votes to close as dupe?
The challenge author voted to closed it as a dupe
See this MSE post: New UI encourages askers to confirm or dispute duplicate votes
Essentially, when a user votes to close a question as a duplicate, ...
- 49.4k
5
votes
Reposts of answer-chaining challenges
This should not be allowed, but we could lower the threshold for these challenges to be considered a "duplicate".
The reason that we don't allow reposts is because the same answers will be ...
- 58.9k
5
votes
Is "(The other day) I met a bear" a duplicate?
No, it's not a duplicate.
In my opinion, we should think of duplicates as challenges which are sufficiently similar to past challenges that very little or nothing is added to the site by having the ...
- 42k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible