38
votes
Accepted
Is code golf going to be opting into the voting reputation requirement test?
No
Code Golf participating would provide minimal useful information for Stack Exchange given our unique format, and it would solve a problem we really don't have (insufficient voting/interaction).
In ...
- 18.9k
32
votes
Offering a bounty in exchange for upvotes
This is not allowed. I've removed the offer.
Stack Exchange works by ensuring that the best information rises to the top. Thus, the motivation for upvoting a post needs to be anchored in the merits ...
- 211k
23
votes
Accepted
Why are all the answers here being downvoted?
I am the person who downvoted. I am not afraid "to come forward", as many have speculated. I don't believe that I have done anything wrong, and I am rather certain I have not broken any rules.
So ...
Wheat WizardMod
- 100k
22
votes
Accepted
Don't downvote off topic posts into oblivion
posts that are unintentionally against our on-topic guidelines have no reason to be downvoted.
This is false; posts with a score of -4 or lower do not appear on the front page.
Making low quality ...
- 211k
19
votes
Why are some users so quick to jump on a bandwagon?
Conservation of nitpicking
I want to give a pragmatic answer on the need for nitpicking. By nitpicks, I mean tedious-seeming inquiries on minor points like "Can the list be empty?" or "...
- 147k
17
votes
Incentives for answering old questions
Run a monthly contest
We have an annual contest which attracts quite a bit of attention to the winners inherently, and a bit more because it uses bounties for prizes. It's too process-heavy to run ...
- 43.1k
17
votes
Newbie question about voting
Voting while participating
As it's a contest it doesn't make sense to vote for other answers - does it?
It is a contest, but I like to think of it as a challenge. And everyone participates ...
- 46.5k
14
votes
Should I upvote an answer based on how much it was improved?
No one can tell you how to vote
Voting is a very subjective thing. Some people are liberal, others not so much. Ultimately, you should upvote or downvote an answer (or question) if you think it's ...
- 50.3k
14
votes
Newbie question about voting
Do not vote for code length!
Code length is not a good way to determine what to vote for, because it isn't a good indicator of quality. A golflang submission can be thoroughly uninteresting and still ...
- 15.5k
12
votes
Incentives for answering old questions
Clarify how to handle changing standards
Visibility and incentives aside, answering old questions is awkward because of changing site standards. I've given up on submissions I started to write ...
- 147k
11
votes
Should I upvote an answer based on how much it was improved?
I think the direct answer ought to be 'NO: you should not upvote an answer based on whether it was improved.'
If this was common practice, it could encourage answerers to deliberately submit ...
- 36.4k
10
votes
Is it permitted to upvote only to test submissions?
Absolutely not
In general
Targeted upvoting – i.e., upvoting because of the poster instead of the post itself – is forbidden on the entire network and can have unpleasant consequences both for the ...
- 211k
10
votes
Why are all the answers here being downvoted?
You shouldn't use moderator flags for this purpose -- I don't know what you expect me to do. Information about individual votes is private, even for moderators.
Presumably whoever cast these votes is ...
- 71.7k
10
votes
Accepted
2 downvotes + 1 upvote = 1 more reputation
Reddit karma is +1/-1. Why should SE rep be +10/-2?
In short, the voting and reputation structure are optimized for a Q/A site rather than a system that ranks popular opinions.
There is asymmetry in ...
- 21.5k
9
votes
Newer users can't view vote counts, therefore cannot view current site consensus
Converting my deleted comment into an answer for more visibility
While this is a popular idea (and something I personally support), changing this isn't going to happen, but there is an easy way around ...
- 50.3k
9
votes
An experiment into the FGITW phenomenon
These are some very interesting and, unfortunately, not-too-surprising results. I do think the FGITW phenomenon is quite disappointing and discouraging for what I'd say are higher quality and higher ...
- 42.6k
8
votes
Accepted
Can deleted answers be down-voted?
No
If a user that can see deleted posts tries to downvote one, they will get the message:
This post has been deleted; deleted posts can't be voted on
However, due to a known bug horrible design ...
- 59.6k
7
votes
Why are some users so quick to jump on a bandwagon?
I can only speak to the nitpicking point since I haven't seen any examples of the first point that I can remember. About this second point I have two things to say:
Nitpicking
First off nit picking ...
Wheat WizardMod
- 100k
6
votes
Why are some users so quick to jump on a bandwagon?
Why do users nitpick questions?
Because it makes the challenges better (and hence, more fun for everyone), and evens the playing field.
I'm bringing this specific example up because I spent two hours ...
- 2,791
5
votes
Why are some users so quick to jump on a bandwagon?
I can't comment on the "bandwagon", as doing so would include making assumptions about people's motivations for voting, while these cannot easily be determined.
Regarding nitpicking, note ...
- 31.1k
5
votes
Accepted
Do you gain reputation from upvotes from the meta site
No.
I've upvoted your question for you to verify this.
From the What is "meta"? How does it work? page:
Votes on meta do not affect your reputation; your meta reputation is the same as your ...
- 31.1k
4
votes
Why are some users so quick to jump on a bandwagon?
There are several questions in one; I'll share my perspective on some of them.
people are downvoted simply because ... it uses a different approach
We try to downvote content, not people. I can ...
- 13.9k
4
votes
How do we score colors in Desmos?
Setting the color is not part of the language
As defined here, there is no way to encode the color. This means that the color of the graph is not part of the language, similar to how setting the ...
- 14.5k
4
votes
You haven't voted on questions in a while
This is good for the site
I'm going to expand a bit on what Christopher has said.
Good questions on this site are difficult to write and extremely valuable for the site. For most sites the goal is ...
Wheat WizardMod
- 100k
4
votes
Add an option to disable upvoting for your post
So, voting for (correct) answers is superfluous, if you think about it.
I've thought about it, and I remain thoroughly unconvinced. Even if posting is its own reward (and that is antithetical to the ...
- 43.1k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible